Some of the hardware options that I'm pondering...
I'm leaning toward the combination of the last two pictured (Although the Baldwin designs are lovely, I'm not sure they're different enough to justify the higher price tag.) Ideally, I would love to find perfectly aged brass hardware... but, from browsing the online offerings, I am not loving the "antique" or "aged" brass finishes that I'm finding. I prefer the tarnished/spotty look - rather than the brushed look. So, I think I'm going to go with polished brass. It is a very common choice for colonial homes like ours, and I think it always look classy on a black front door.